Reviewed by Marcus Knapman, BSc (Hons) Computing ·
Researched from 100+ Amazon customer reviews
· How we review
If you've spent any time on BookTok, you've probably seen Keeping 13 plastered across your feed with teary-eyed readers clutching their Kindles. Chloe Walsh's rugby romance has become something of a phenomenon, and at 99p, it's practically throwing itself at you. I'll admit, I was sceptical. Sports romance isn't usually my cup of tea, and the TikTok hype machine has burned me before with books that promise the earth and deliver soggy biscuits.
But here's the thing about Keeping 13 — it's not just another formulaic romance dressed up with Irish accents and rugby shorts. This is the third book in Walsh's Boys of Tommen series, and whilst you could theoretically jump in here, you'd be doing yourself a disservice. The emotional weight of this story builds on everything that's come before, particularly Johnny and Shannon's relationship from the previous books.
Johnny Kavanagh is rugby's golden boy with demons that would make a therapist rich, whilst Shannon Lynch carries scars that run deeper than anyone realises. Their relationship has been building through the series, and Keeping 13 is where Walsh finally lets them have their moment — though she puts them through absolute hell first.
What sets this apart from other YA romance is Walsh's unflinching approach to mental health. Johnny's struggles with anxiety and self-harm aren't glossed over or magically cured by love. Shannon's trauma from her abusive home life isn't used as mere backstory decoration. These are real issues handled with surprising maturity for a book targeted at teenagers.
I've read sports romances where the sport feels like window dressing, but Walsh clearly knows her rugby. The descriptions of training, matches, and team dynamics feel authentic without drowning you in technical jargon. More importantly, rugby isn't just Johnny's hobby — it's his lifeline, his identity, and potentially his destruction all rolled into one.
The pressure Johnny faces as Tommen's star player creates genuine tension. You feel the weight of expectation crushing him, and when things go wrong, the stakes feel real rather than manufactured drama.
Fair warning: this book will wreck you emotionally. Walsh doesn't pull her punches when it comes to depicting the realities of abuse, mental illness, and family dysfunction. The Lynch family situation is particularly harrowing, and there are scenes that genuinely made me uncomfortable — which is probably the point.
Some readers have complained that it's too heavy, too intense for what should be escapist romance. I understand that criticism, but I also think it's what makes the book memorable. The darkness makes the light moments feel earned rather than handed out freely.
Walsh has a talent for writing dialogue that feels natural — no small feat when your characters are Irish teenagers. The banter between Johnny and his teammates is particularly well done, capturing that specific brand of masculine affection that exists in sports teams.
Where the writing occasionally stumbles is in pacing. There are stretches where the emotional intensity becomes almost overwhelming, and I found myself needing breaks between chapters. It's not necessarily a flaw, but it's worth knowing what you're signing up for.
Here's where things get interesting from a value perspective. At 99p, Keeping 13 is cheaper than a coffee, and it'll last considerably longer. Even if you end up hating it, you're out less than a pound. But if you're like most readers who've discovered this series, you'll immediately want to buy the rest.
The low price point is clearly a hook to get you invested in the series, and it works. Walsh has created characters you genuinely care about, which makes the inevitable book hangover when you finish particularly brutal.
Keeping 13 delivers on its emotional promises, even if it occasionally threatens to drown you in feelings. If you're looking for light, fluffy romance, look elsewhere. But if you want a story that treats its characters' struggles with respect and delivers genuine emotional payoff, this is worth your time and 99p.
As an Amazon Associate, Smart Trends earns from qualifying purchases.
Was this review helpful?